Nov 17, 2026
Washington, D.C.
The Supreme Court on Monday denied review in two cases that will not, for now, change the law, and that Justice Clarence Thomas declined to let pass in silence. As SCOTUSblog reported, the orders came from Friday’s conference and were released with the rest of the list Monday morning.
In Khatibi v. Yip, the Court refused to hear a California ophthalmologist’s challenge to a 2022 state rule requiring private instructors in privately run, privately accredited continuing medical education courses to discuss “how so-called implicit bias affects healthcare outcomes.” The Ninth Circuit had held that the First Amendment did not even apply, because the breadth of California’s CME regulation made the content of any such course government speech. Thomas, joined by Justice Samuel Alito, dissented from the denial. Justice Neil Gorsuch would have granted review but did not join the dissent. “First Amendment protections do not give way simply because a State heavily regulates speech,” Thomas wrote. He would have granted certiorari “to clarify the government-speech doctrine,” and he called California’s requirement “an evident attempt to regulate private expression.” The dissent is here.
In Novotny v. Moore, the Court refused a Second Amendment challenge to Maryland laws that, as Thomas listed them, forbid a law-abiding person to carry a firearm at public demonstrations, on mass transit, in places of amusement, in healthcare facilities, in establishments that sell alcohol for on-site consumption, and across tens of thousands of acres of state park and forest land. The Fourth Circuit had upheld the restrictions as bans in “sensitive places.” Thomas filed a statement respecting the denial. He is “skeptical” that each of those laws “is consistent with this Nation’s historical tradition of firearm regulation” in sensitive places, the test the Court set out in New York State Rifle & Pistol Assn. v. Bruen. He agreed, even so, that the petition was the wrong vehicle: the challenge was so broad that it would “complicate” review. “In an appropriate and more narrowly focused case, however, we should consider the scope of States’ authority to ban firearms in ‘sensitive places.’”
Thomas’s gun statement is worth reading for the map it draws. New Jersey, he noted, now lists at least 25 forbidden locations, including zoos, public libraries, casinos, and state-owned beaches. New York has designated 20, ranging from “any place of worship” to certain residential health settings. California has 29, including athletic facilities, financial institutions, and any government-permitted public gathering. “These restrictions stand on questionable historical ground,” he wrote. “And, their cumulative effect is to prohibit firearms wherever people gather for eating, drinking, recreation, amusement, and free speech—an affront to the right of ‘law-abiding citizens’ to ‘carr[y] arms in public for’ their ‘ordinary self-defense.’”
The speech case is the other half of the same temptation: a state that cannot bear an unofficial sentence will call the sentence official. If a private doctor, teaching a private course for private credit, can be made to recite the state’s theory of implicit bias because the state licenses physicians, then the government-speech doctrine has become a solvent. It will dissolve whatever it is poured over. Thomas is right that Shurtleff v. Boston is being read as if regulation itself were authorship. It is not.
Lucid will say this, as opinion: a denial is not an endorsement, and a statement respecting a denial is not a ruling. The Court was cautious, perhaps even prudent, to wait for a narrower gun case. Caution is not the same as comfort. A right that may be exercised only in the leftover spaces—neither the hospital nor the train, neither the park nor the gathering, and, in New York, not even the church—is a right that has been theoretically preserved and practically boxed in. A classroom that may teach medicine only if it also preaches a contested theory of bias is a classroom that has been conscripted. The justices did not take these cases. Thomas left two markers on the list, so that the next counsel, and the next conference, will know where the argument still stands.
References
Photo by Han Zheng via Wikimedia Commons, licensed under CC BY-SA 2.0; cropped and color-adjusted.
or register to join the conversation.
Join the discussion
0 comments