The Strait of Hormuz
On Monday morning, the United Kingdom Maritime Trade Operations centre reported that a tanker transiting outbound through the Strait of Hormuz had been struck by an “unidentified projectile.” The hit started a fire in the engine room. All of the crew were accounted for; no casualties were reported. The extent of the damage, and of any environmental harm, was not yet clear. UKMTO did not name the ship. Some maritime reports later identified it as the Panama-flagged tanker On Phoenix.
That is the hard fact. Much else is a claim. Iran’s Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps said two tankers struck mines in the southern strait on Sunday and more on Monday, and it put the number of tankers that had caught fire since Sunday at six, with at least one supposed sinking. Iran’s Army Navy, separately, said a “violator” tanker hit a mine east of the strait, caught fire, and could not move. As Euronews noted, and as Seatrade Maritime and the Jewish Institute for National Security of America likewise recorded, those Iranian accounts have not been independently confirmed. A British maritime authority described a projectile and a fire. Tehran described a minefield. Those are not the same sentence.
A day earlier, UKMTO had already relayed a report from Indian shipping authorities of a tanker attacked in the Arabian Gulf as it approached the strait. Seatrade Maritime, citing the security firm Vanguard Tech, identified that vessel as the ADNOC-managed very large crude carrier Al Dhannah, struck in the steering gear and listed by Iran as non-compliant. Stars and Stripes, drawing on U.K. maritime and International Maritime Organization figures, reported at least fourteen attacks on commercial ships in the strait and nearby waters so far this month, after thirty-five in October. In March there were nineteen confirmed attacks.
On Sunday, Iran launched six drones at the Riffa helicopter base in Bahrain, the first such attack on the island since early September, Stars and Stripes reported. Bahrain said it intercepted and destroyed several projectiles. The Revolutionary Guards claimed a “successful impact.” U.S. Central Command, per Euronews, denied damage to American assets. Naval Support Activity Bahrain, headquarters of the Fifth Fleet, sits about eleven miles from Riffa and has been struck repeatedly since the war began in February.
Euronews reported that the United States then struck Iranian missile launchers at Bandar Lengeh and Sirik in southern Iran on Sunday night. Lucid will record that as reporting, not as a communiqué. CENTCOM had not, in the accounts reviewed here, issued a public confirmation of those particular targets. The same weekend, according to The Wall Street Journal and Axios as cited by Stars and Stripes, the aircraft carrier USS Theodore Roosevelt entered the Central Command area of operations, joining USS George Washington and USS George H.W. Bush. CENTCOM did not immediately confirm the arrival to Stars and Stripes. It would be the second time this year that three American carriers have been in the Middle East. Whether Roosevelt stays as a third deck or relieves one of the other two was, as of Monday, unclear.
The economic pressure is not a rumor. Stars and Stripes, citing CENTCOM earlier this month, reported that U.S. forces had turned away 150 commercial ships and disabled five others, blocking Tehran from exporting more than $30 billion in crude. President Trump said last week, on Truth Social, that the United States does not need a deal with Iran, and that “we’ve got their Strait.”
Lucid will say this, as opinion: a strait is a fact of geography, and therefore a fact of force. It is not a metaphor, and it is not a treaty. A blockade can starve a treasury; it cannot, by itself, convert a revolutionary theocracy into a neighbor. A mine, if it is a mine, is not a harbor regulation. A projectile, if it is a projectile, is not an accident of navigation. The honest work is to keep the two vocabularies apart, so that a claim shouted from Tehran is not confused with a report filed in London, and so that three carriers are understood for what they are: a concentration of American power in a narrow sea, not a conclusion. The engine room caught fire. The crew lived. That is enough, for one morning, to remind a serious country that the waterway was never a theory.
References
Photo by Petty Officer 2nd Class Ikia Walker, U.S. Navy, via Wikimedia Commons, public domain; cropped and color-adjusted.
or register to join the conversation.
Join the discussion
0 comments