Washington, D.C.

The suspension of Jimmy Kimmel after his reckless comments about Charlie Kirk and President Trump has exposed a glaring double standard in America’s cultural and political debate over free speech. Celebrities like Sophia Bush immediately took to X, declaring, “The First Amendment doesn’t exist in America anymore. Period. Fascism is here and it’s chilling.” MSNBC’s Chris Hayes followed suit, suggesting Kimmel’s firing rendered the First Amendment “meaningless.”

But when conservatives like Tucker Carlson faced cancellation, the very same voices applauded it. Hayes himself once mocked Carlson’s dismissal, sneering, “He believed he could say anything no matter how disgusting and get away with it. Over time, that’s not going to work out well for you.” The hypocrisy is as clear as it is destructive.

Jimmy Kimmel’s Reckless Falsehood

Let’s establish the facts. Jimmy Kimmel did not simply “criticize” Charlie Kirk or Donald Trump. He made a verifiably false claim: that the man who assassinated Charlie Kirk was connected to the MAGA movement. There is no evidence that this was true. It was a smear, an attempt to tie a tragic murder to Trump supporters in order to discredit the political right.

Adding insult, Kimmel mocked President Trump’s grieving process, deriding him as someone incapable of mourning a friend. This wasn’t edgy comedy. It was slander mixed with cruelty, weaponizing a national tragedy for political theater. In any serious society, accountability for such lies is not censorship; it is the bare minimum.

Sophia Bush and Manufactured Outrage

Sophia Bush’s claim that Kimmel’s suspension proves the First Amendment is “dead” is disingenuous. The First Amendment prevents government prosecution of speech, not the private consequences of defamation, slander, or reckless speech that undermines trust and truth.

Where was Bush’s defense of free expression when conservatives were canceled en masse for questioning COVID policies, gender ideology, or election integrity? Where was her alarm when everyday Americans lost jobs or were de-platformed for sharing opinions the Left deemed “misinformation”? She and her Hollywood peers not only stood by but actively cheered it on.

The outrage only surfaces when the consequences land on one of their own.

Chris Hayes: The Double Standard in Action

Chris Hayes’ reaction reveals the rot at the core of the Left’s narrative. Today, he paints Kimmel as a free speech martyr, declaring his suspension “renders the First Amendment meaningless.” Yet when Tucker Carlson was pushed out, Hayes gleefully declared Carlson brought it on himself: “He believed he could say anything no matter how disgusting and get away with it. Over time, that’s not going to work out well for you.”

So when a conservative is silenced, the Left calls it justice. When a liberal faces consequences, suddenly it’s “fascism.” That’s not a principled defense of speech; it’s a partisan ploy.

Was This Trump’s FCC?

Sophia Bush and others have tried to spin the suspension as a “government demand,” with Theo Baker suggesting ABC acted under threats from Trump’s FCC. Here are the facts. The FCC cannot order a specific show or host off the air. It regulates spectrum licenses and applies a vague “public interest” standard that courts have allowed for broadcasters, but it does not micromanage program content. On Benny Johnson’s podcast, FCC Chair Brendan Carr did use hard-edged rhetoric, saying affiliates could “do this the easy way or the hard way” and urging them to “take actions, frankly on Kimmel,” while invoking the Commission’s authority and even analogizing Kimmel’s monologue to “news distortion.” On Fox News later that evening, Carr emphasized that broadcasters (unlike cable or streaming) have a license-based duty to serve the public interest and praised affiliates for “standing up to serve the interests of their community,” calling the Nexstar and Sinclair moves “unprecedented.” Those statements were aggressive, but they were not a binding order, notice, or sanction. No FCC docket, letter, or enforcement action exists.

Equally important, the two big affiliate groups publicly state they acted on their own. Nexstar’s spokesperson said the decision to preempt Jimmy Kimmel Live! “was made unilaterally by the senior executive team at Nexstar” with “no communication with the FCC or any government agency prior to making that decision.” Sinclair issued its own release demanding a direct apology to Kirk’s family and conditions for any return, and scheduled a Charlie Kirk tribute in Kimmel’s slot. In short, affiliates exercised their carriage rights. ABC/Disney then chose an indefinite suspension. That sequence, plus the absence of any formal FCC action, undercuts the claim that “Trump’s FCC ordered ABC to yank Kimmel.”

This also highlights a crucial distinction: the Constitution restrains the state, not private individuals or companies. Private employers or organizations may respond to speech with consequences, and that is not a First Amendment violation. Free speech protections apply when the government seeks to suppress or punish expression. The constitutional right protects citizens from state action, not from accountability in the workplace or marketplace. Thus, if ABC, Sinclair, or Nexstar dismissed Jimmy Kimmel for his words, that would be a corporate decision, not an act of government censorship. On the record today, this is not government coercion; it is affiliates and a network making programming calls in response to a host’s verifiably false claim.

Who Really Canceled Free Speech?

The truth is unavoidable: the Left has spent years weaponizing speech. They invented “hate speech” categories to silence disagreement. They pressured platforms to purge dissent under the guise of “misinformation.” They celebrated the canceling of conservatives, pastors, professors, journalists, and ordinary citizens alike.

Now, when accountability lands on Jimmy Kimmel for a false and inflammatory claim, they cry that the Constitution has been shredded. No, the Constitution stands. What doesn’t stand is their credibility.

The Real Crisis

The real crisis in America is not conservatives “canceling” speech. It’s the Left redefining speech itself. If they disagree with you, it’s hate. If you question them, it’s misinformation. If you expose them, it’s dangerous. And when one of their own is held to the same standard, they cry “fascism.”

That’s not free speech; it’s manipulation.

Accountability Is Not Censorship

Sophia Bush and Chris Hayes want Americans to believe Jimmy Kimmel’s suspension marks the death of the First Amendment. In truth, it highlights the deep hypocrisy of a cultural elite that has spent years silencing conservatives while cloaking itself in the language of liberty. The First Amendment is alive. What’s dying is the Left’s monopoly on defining truth.

References

• Sophia Bush on X: “The First Amendment doesn’t exist in America anymore”
• Theo Baker on Trump FCC and Kimmel suspension
• Chris Hayes on Tucker Carlson’s dismissal
• The Twitter Files: Government-Big Tech collusion
  ‍

Photo by Markus Winkler on Unsplash