Obedience Was Never the End Goal

America was not built by people who merely obeyed well.

It was built by people who knew when obedience had reached its limit.

The crisis facing the American Right today is not a lack of ideas, policy papers, or correct arguments. It is a failure of virtue, specifically, a failure to practice the full range of virtues the Founders believed a free people required.

They identified three categories. We kept two. We abandoned the third.

And that is why we are losing.

The Social Virtues: Endurance, Not Endless Submission

The Founders did not believe a free people should revolt at the first inconvenience. They explicitly warned against that kind of instability. Ordered liberty requires patience, restraint, and a willingness to suffer for the common good.

But that endurance was never meant to be infinite.

As the Declaration of Independence puts it:

“Prudence, indeed, will dictate that Governments long established should not be changed for light and transient causes; and accordingly all experience hath shewn, that mankind are more disposed to suffer, while evils are sufferable, than to right themselves by abolishing the forms to which they are accustomed.”

That sentence matters.

The Founders assumed obedience under inconvenience, patience under imperfect rule, and restraint in the face of irritation. Those are social virtues, and they are necessary for any stable society.

But the very next clause draws the boundary:

“But when a long train of abuses and usurpations… evinces a design to reduce them under absolute Despotism, it is their right, it is their duty, to throw off such Government.”

Endurance has a limit.

Suffering has a threshold.

The problem on the Right today is not that we value restraint; it is that we have forgotten the limit.

We still believe in suffering for the public good.

We no longer believe in recognizing when suffering has become submission.

The Founders never made that mistake.

The Republican Virtues: Necessary but Incomplete

The second category is the republican virtues.

Industry, frugality, and self-reliance are the habits of free men who do not depend on patrons or the state.

Again, the Right excels here.

Conservatives work. They build. They provide. They pay their taxes. They raise families. They leave cities rather than fight over them. They opt out rather than confront.

But self-reliance without public assertion produces a paradox: free men who will not defend their freedom.

A republic cannot survive on productivity alone. Someone must be willing to contest power.

The Missing Piece: Virtues of Self-Assertion

The Founders were explicit about the third category: the virtues of self-assertion.

Courage.

Fortitude.

Vigilance.

Readiness to oppose violations of the people’s just rights.

These virtues are uncomfortable. They disrupt peace. They invite conflict. And they do not harmonize neatly with self-restraint.

That tension is not a flaw. It is the cost of liberty.

The Right has largely abandoned these virtues, and the Left has not.

Why the Left Keeps Winning at the Ground Level

The Left organizes.

The Left shows up.

The Left applies pressure early, publicly, and relentlessly.

They practice vigilance, even in service of bad ideas.

The Right, by contrast, waits. It waits for courts to intervene, for elections years away, for permission, and for someone else to act.

This is not prudence. It is paralysis.

The Founders did not design liberty to be protected by judges alone. They assumed a feisty, public-spirited citizenry, men and women ready to assert themselves before institutions fully harden against them.

Grassroots Assertion Is Not Violence

Let’s be clear.

Assertion is not lawlessness.

Assertion is not rioting.

Assertion is not chaos.

Assertion means organized presence, disciplined protest, public resistance, institutional pressure, and refusal to be ignored.

It is the willingness to make injustice costly, socially, politically, and reputationally.

Every successful movement in American history understood this. The Right is the first to forget it.

A Republic Requires Woven Virtues

The ancient philosophers described statesmanship as the art of weaving together opposite virtues.

Moderation and courage.

Restraint and assertion.

Peace and readiness to fight.

America succeeded because it achieved this balance for nearly two centuries.

We are now lopsided, overdeveloped in obedience and underdeveloped in vigilance.

And imbalance always collapses.

The Call to Action

The Right does not need to become cruel.

But it must stop being passive.

Recover the courage to show up.

Recover the willingness to confront power early.

Recover the discipline to organize locally and persist publicly.

Because a people who will not assert their rights will eventually be ruled by those who will.

The Founders knew this.

The Left practices it.

The Right must relearn it.

Not tomorrow.

Not after the next ruling.

Now.

References

• The Declaration of Independence (1776)
• Founding-era political writings and civic philosophy

‍