Washington, D.C.
On Thursday the Senate rejected H.Con.Res. 93, a war-powers resolution directing the president, under section 5(c) of the War Powers Resolution, to remove United States Armed Forces from hostilities with Iran. The official tally, recorded by the Senate Daily Press, was 48 in favor and 51 against. Three Republicans—Sens. Susan Collins of Maine, Lisa Murkowski of Alaska, and Rand Paul of Kentucky—voted aye. Sen. John Fetterman, Democrat of Pennsylvania, voted no. Sen. Chris Murphy, Democrat of Connecticut, who has been recovering from a stroke, did not vote.
It was, as Stars and Stripes reported, the first congressional vote on the conflict since Democrats won the midterm elections. The same measure had passed the House in September, 220 to 204, and did not have the force of law. A concurrent resolution is one chamber, or both, speaking; it does not go to the president’s desk. The Associated Press, via WTOP, noted that Democrats have forced such votes all year, that the Senate even approved a war-powers resolution in June and reversed itself the next day after a closed-door lunch with President Trump, and that about six in ten voters, in the AP Voter Poll, said the United States made the “wrong decision” in taking military action against Iran.
Sen. Tim Kaine, Democrat of Virginia, who has led the war-powers effort, said, “The American public is tired of it,” and tired as well of higher gasoline and diesel prices “that have gone up and punished Americans since the war.” Sens. Peter Welch of Vermont and Tammy Baldwin of Wisconsin said voters had made their view of the war, launched by the United States and Israel in February, “very clear.” Baldwin added, “Every day this war goes on, we are risking the lives of service members.” Stars and Stripes, citing the Pentagon, reported 23 U.S. service-member deaths in operations connected to the conflict and more than 850 injuries.
Sen. Tim Sheehy, Republican of Montana and a former Navy SEAL, spoke against the resolution. “We should finish the job, protect this nation and protect our allies,” he said. “Iran is not a war of choice, it’s a war of necessity because the Ayatollah decided 47 years ago that he was going to claim death to America and do so in every way possible.” Sen. Thom Tillis, Republican of North Carolina, voted no, having backed a previous bid to end the war. Collins, who was defeated for reelection this month, voted yes. Democrats, Stars and Stripes reported, say they will keep pushing war-powers votes and may use appropriations once they take control of Congress in January.
Lucid will say this, as opinion: the Constitution gives Congress the power to declare war, and a Congress that will not use that power will eventually discover that someone else has used it for them. A vote is better than a shrug. A concurrent resolution that cannot bind the commander-in-chief is not yet a declaration, and it is not yet an ending. The War Powers Resolution was written after Vietnam to put a clock on undeclared fighting; clocks are useless if the legislature will not keep them. The Senate was right to take a recorded vote. It was not, by that vote, finishing a job, or ending a war, or reclaiming a power it has mostly lent away. Forty-eight to fifty-one is a fact. The war, as of Thursday night, was another.
References
Photo by peakfocus.agency via Wikimedia Commons, licensed under CC BY 4.0; cropped and color-adjusted.
or register to join the conversation.
Join the discussion
0 comments