San Francisco
On Thursday, U.S. District Judge Trina Thompson, in the Northern District of California, held that expressly Christian messages sent by Agriculture Secretary Brooke Rollins to USDA employees likely violated the First Amendment’s Establishment Clause. The case is National Federation of Federal Employees v. U.S. Department of Agriculture. As Eugene Volokh reported, quoting the opinion at length, the judge ordered the secretary to “recognize certain boundaries when communicating religious messages,” including limits already set out in a USDA memorandum: she must stop if a colleague asks her to stop; she cannot create a hostile work environment; she cannot use official authority to pressure subordinates. The court expressed “no view whatsoever on what the Secretary can and cannot do in her personal capacity.”
The record, as the court recited it, included an official Independence Day message ending, “May God continue to protect the United States of America and may His favor shine over all her land,” and a Thanksgiving message attributing the first Thanksgiving in part to “gratitude towards a loving God.” The judge reserved her sharpest language for two later emails. On Dec. 23, 2025, Rollins sent a Christmas message with a video stating that “The spirit of generosity flows from the very first Christmas when God gave us the greatest gift possible, the gift of his Son and our Savior Jesus Christ.” On April 5, 2026, she emailed “All USDA Employees” an Easter letter that began, “Happy Easter – He is Risen indeed!” called the Resurrection “the foundation of our faith, and the abiding hope of all mankind,” compared the staff to “the very first disciples,” and was headed by an illustration of the empty tomb and the words “Christ is Risen.” Those two messages, the court said, “go too far.”
Judge Thompson found coercion in three facts: Rollins’s authority, her use of the official email to reach the whole department, and language that, with “we,” “us,” and “our,” treated Christian belief as the staff’s shared faith. Plaintiffs said they felt pressure to conceal their own beliefs; the judge wrote that immense social pressure can amount to coercion, and that the secretary appeared “to exploit her position of authority to convey a religious message beyond mere holiday wishes.” The administration argued, Axios reported, that the messages fell “within this Nation’s deeply rooted history and tradition of religious invocations in official discourse, including on holidays.” A USDA spokesperson called the decision “a completely unprecedented attempt to muzzle a Cabinet Secretary” and said the department was “evaluating all options including a prompt appeal.”
The court quoted Rollins as saying, of her office, “I do use this platform [as the Secretary of Agriculture]. I believe in making disciples of all nations.… I have been sued a couple of times for, they say, talking about Jesus too much, but I’ll never stop talking about Jesus.”
Lucid will say this, as opinion: the Establishment Clause was written to keep the federal government from erecting a church, not to keep a cabinet secretary from saying, on Easter, that Christ is risen. The Supreme Court, in Kennedy v. Bremerton School District, warned that the government need not “purge from the public sphere” everything an observer might call religious. A holiday letter can become a test of belonging; that is a serious charge, and it should be proved as a practice of punishment or preferment, not inferred from a first-person plural on a feast day. The judge is right that a secretary may not make a Christian profession a condition of employment at the Department of Agriculture. She is wrong if she treats an Easter proclamation, sent once a year from an official inbox, as the same thing as an established church. The apostles were not civil servants. The civil servants are not a congregation. A country that can no longer bear the words “He is risen” in a public building has not become more neutral. It has only become more nervous.
References
Photo by the U.S. Department of Agriculture via Wikimedia Commons, public domain; cropped and color-adjusted.
or register to join the conversation.
Join the discussion
0 comments